My Thoughts on Rugs

A while back I posted about the new rug in the sun room and a reader left this comment:
Picking out rugs is so hard. I always end up leaning towards really generic colors and patterns. Because even a couple hundred dollars is enough of an investment to me that I don't want to get tired of it and I don't want to have to replace it until it's worn out. I'd love to hear your tips on how to choose a rug that will accent a room but not look dated in a year (or five).

I have been thinking about rugs ever since I read this comment.  I think we can all agree that committing to certain items that go into our homes can be a challenge - especially the expensive ones.  I for one wonder if I will like (fill in the blank with item of your choice) next year.  This holds true even when I have the opportunity to review a "free" rug.  Sometimes it is simply hard to make a decision.  If you have followed my blog for a while, then you know that I have changed my mind a time or two.  One of those changes included getting rid of an oriental rug with colors that just "no longer worked".  Which brings me back to the question, "how do you choose a rug that won't look dated in a year (or five)?"

Well, good question - and not one that can easily be answered.  First let me say that there are several rugs that I consider to be timeless.  When I think of timeless rugs, I think of sisal and seagrass.  I also think of Turkish and oriental.  Then the modern girl in me ventures into the modern classics like stripes, trellis, and geometrics.  Which one is the best option?  It all depends on your lifestyle, end use, furnishings, and taste.  I don't think there is a right or wrong answer.

Let's look at some rooms...

 Seagrass
Cottage and Vine


If I could only pick one rug for the rest of my life that would go into every room in our home, I would pick something in the seagrass/sisal family.  If you had asked me this same question when our babies were in the crawling stage the answer would have been to go with something softer.  My guys aren't the best at wiping their feet before entering the house and neither is our dog.  So these rugs are by far the best for us given our current lifestyle.  A quick pass with the vacuum and it is clean.  Clearly the size is wrong now that the furniture has moved, but until then, it is what it is.

Traditional Home

Seagrass rugs relax traditional interiors and add warmth to modern ones.  


Pinterest

 
The neutral color is like a blank canvas that frees you to take more risks with color in accessories & fabrics.  Is this really an accent rug?  No, which leads me to the next style.

 Persian/Turkish/Kelim

Cottage and Vine


What if your room calls for something with more color?  Take our black and white bathroom for example.  This tiny little rug gave it just the pop it needed to keep the room from being boring.  Colorful rugs work especially well when the rest of the room is calm....


 Apartment Therapy

...or in this case modern.  I really like the character a kelim rug adds to a streamlined, modern kitchen.  And in this case, the colors balance out the yellow tones in the floor.



Pinterest


Generous doses of white mixed with neutral fabrics are key to making this rug work.  And did you notice, it is also layered over a seagrass rug?
 Modern
 Cottage and Vine
 While some modern rugs tend to be more on the trendy side, I believe certain ones are here to stay.  There will always be a place for a stripe, trellis, or animal pattern.  Because the pattern alone gives a graphic punch the colors can be more on the neutral side which may "work" for longer in your home.

 Lynn Morgan Design

I really love what this striped rug does for this room.  It looks modern, but not cold - very live-able.  The pillows could easily be switched out to come up with a whole new look/feel for the room.  




 House Beautiful

Those are my thoughts, now I would love to hear what you think.

24 comments:

  1. i always love fun patterned rugs, but i find i tire of them quickly... plus with 2 dogs i often keep wood floors rugless so i don't cry when they ruin my expensive rug!
    they can do so much for a space and really define it, so maybe when i don't have dogs i will invest more in rugs. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Really like these tips. We have an old Karastan rug that I was really tiring of a couple of years ago. Because it is so beautiful and durable, I couldn't justify getting rid of it. We decided to buy a seagrass rug and switched out the more traditional rug after the winter holidays. We love the clean look of seagrass through mid-September, then we trade again for the cozy wool rug. It's a half step to making a real change, but it works really well for us.

    I would recommend wool to anyone who wants a really durable good-looking rug. We have a dog and three kids and the rug just looks better and better every year. I've even knocked over a gallon of paint on it when I was painting my mantle and it cleaned up easily.

    ReplyDelete
  3. great tips. I am completely drawn to seagrass and sisal rugs. They do seem timeless to me and can work in just about any room with any colors. I recently wanted to purchase a more modern pattern rug, but couldn't pul the trigger because I knew I would tire of it easily and can't bring myself to buy into a trend that is that expensive. Love all the pictures!

    ReplyDelete
  4. i love the natural look of a jute, seagrass, or sisal rug - i agree they are timeless. i have a hard time committing too - in need of one for my dining room but cant seem to bite the bullet just yet :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. For our family, sea grass is the way to go-- I'm slowly replacing every rug with the biggest seagrass I can afford for each room. They are totally indestructable, not really all that bad to hang out on and they instantly make every room look pulled together and fresh. I love the look of hide or oushak layered over seagrass, too, so that's always an option for changing things up down the road.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm on my third 8x10 rug in our living room, (really high traffic, with no real entry way)in 7 1/2 years. Of them all, I miss my first, a dyed jute rug from Pottery Barn, the most. It showed so little, but the corners were warped and my kids were crawling. Now I have an almost shag like neutral remnant, which is soft, and shows nothing, but it's well, beige. I look forward to somehow reworking that jute rug or something like it someday!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love natural rugs like seagrass and sisal. They make any room feel open and fresh and the neutral color makes it so easy to change colors and accessories. I love that you can dress them up or down. I'm on the hunt for something that looks like a natural fiber rug but is softer underfoot - I would love to replace our wall to wall carpeting with that one day!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with everyone here that sisal and seagrass are wonderful choices for carpeting, for all of your reasons!

    However, we have been choosing a rug for under our dining table in our eating area (the only eating area we have now that the dining room was redone to an office/study). Two rug companies and an interiors friend warned me: yes, crumbs are easily cleaned. But beware: liquids of any sort i.e. wine, coffee, milk, are impossible to get out!

    So, we have gone with a synthetic that mimics sisal: it's ribbed and it's neutral. It arrives next week, so I will certainly be posting all about it!

    ReplyDelete
  9. What a great post!! Rugs are one of those things that I can never make a decision about! While I love the rug in my living room, the real reason I bought it was because it was a great deal, and I knew I wouldn't feel bad about not liking it in a few years!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great tips and suggestions and all of the pictures are wonderful examples. I have wall to wall carpet and a small home, so layering is really hard. For now, I've opted to go with no rugs. Hugs, Marty

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great tips, Rene. And beautiful examples. I just love your living room. I am a huge fan of having the plain simple rug and layering a trendier, smaller one on top. Sort of fun and easy to switch out.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've held off on buying a rug for my formal living room for A YEAR! My taste keeps changing. Plus every time I'm about to pull the trigger, I get cold feet, thinking there might be something better out there. In an odd way, I can now (only slightly) relate to a handful of guys I knew in college who were terrified of commitment. I need rug therapy...

    ReplyDelete
  13. I love sisal, sea grass and jute. I think you just can't go wrong with them. I have several in rooms that have a lot of color, to sort of balance it out. I agree with you on having a little color play in a neutral room, such as that kitchen with all the white. I love a nice area rug in the kitchen...it is a pleasant surprise!

    XO,
    Jane

    ReplyDelete
  14. I am a seagrass girl all the way.....have had it in my house for 20 years [not the same on of course] but it with stands any and all abuse form people and animals. The good thing is that you can layer a smaller rug on it...saving money so that if you tire of it.maybe it is not such a big deal to change out.
    I do agree rugs are hard and one of the most important decisions to me is get the right size...especially in the DR!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for the great tips:)

    Blessings,
    Linda

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hai Dear

    you have a lovely blog… Please check out my blog.I am having a Giveaway in my blog..Please check it out and partcipate in that..
    http://yummytummy-aarthi.blogspot.com/2011/07/homemade-bounty-chocolate-and-giveaway.html

    Aarthi

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great post - I always have a hard time with this too! I think my problem is that I like so many different styles so it's always hard to choose. However, if I had to choose one for a lifetime rug is would be a seagrass/sisal one.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great advice Rene. I am still looking for a rug in my family room and lean toward the jute/sisal but I love the stripes too. Ugh! This has been such a process. :)

    Enjoy your weekend!!!
    xo

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is such a great post. It feels safe and relatively inexpensive to go the sea grass route...but I am looking for a Turkish rug for my kitchen like in your photo. I just bought a graphic blue and white rug for my bedroom. And I LOVE striped rugs...too.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Well, I'm glad to know that I'm not alone in my issues. :) Thanks so much for all this advice and these lovely pictures! This is definitely a post I plan to bookmark and refer to often... particularly when I get distracted by pictures of fun, ultra trendy rugs and start doubting my instincts, which lean towards natural fiber area and geometric flatweave type throw rugs.

    Thanks again and seriously- this post is so, so helpful!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for this post (and the comments are helpful, too). I'm in the process of transitioning from a beautiful old Karastan wool rug to a jute/chenille blend in our living room. I *love* the wool rug, but it's a bit small and a deep, rich red that's beautiful but limits what I can do in the room, color-wise.

    I'm looking forward to trying something more neutral. But I will keep the Karastan and hopefully use it again one day, perhaps in an entryway if we end up in a bigger house.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I have a seagrass rug in our traditional living room, and I definitely agree that it relaxes the space. Lovely pictures. And I love your blog! I am you newest follower!

    ReplyDelete
  23. In the past few months I sold most of the very traditional oriental styled rugs on our first floor and I am starting over. I am spending less per rug this time around because I have realized that wool rugs don't wear out and no matter how "timeless" they may have appeared to be when I bought them, I have changed and I grew tired of them. So now, I buy what I love. I still consider longevity and flexibility. Thus I am doing a lot of black and white this time around but I am not breaking the bank so in five or six years when graphic designs are looking weary and I am relishing a new look I won't feel married to my purchases. If they don't make me ooh and ahh. I move on.
    Pam

    ReplyDelete
  24. This is a great post. My tastes have changed a bit lately. I currently have a pretty graphic floral rug down and I loved the punch of color. But I am thinking of going to something more neutral like sisal. Just so I can have a more calming feel to the room. I've hesitated because I wasn't sure how they would clean. And I don't want on that is super scratchy. I will keep my punches of color on smaller rugs like my kitchen. I do still love them!

    ReplyDelete

I love your comments and read each and every one. Your questions will be answered here or you can email me at cottageandvine@triad.rr.com

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...